Can love with a disabled person last? A Valentine Day’s musing………


In America last year, the famous talk show host Dr Phil uttered the (now infamous) statement that in a relationship where one of the couple is disabled, they “can be his lover or you can be his caregiver, but you can’t be both…. It won’t work, 100 out of 100 times this won’t work”

Now I know nothing of Dr Phil and his show (I’m more of a Phil and Holly fan myself!😉)  but I do know that there’d been one hell of a hoo ha surrounding his comments.

The website “The Mighty that supports people with disabilities, chronic illnesses, mental health issues etc. had a Twitter campaign against it with the hashtag #100outof100. There was a huge backlash against his statement, with people from the US and in the U.K. saying that his claim was totally untrue and offensive. 

Implying that you were ‘insane’ to want to love someone with a disabilty, that people who need care should be single, that maybe disabled people are therefore ‘unloveable‘ and as one tweet said “that no sane healthy person should love and care for a sick partner, because you are a burden, unworthy of an able person’s time, let alone their love”. (@_AbbieCooper)


But there was also a large amount of people saying that he was right so the question in my mind was …

Who was right…….?

As a fairly newly disabled woman, I feel I have a pretty good idea on how these relationships work, or not work as the case may be. Also as someone who has become disabled whilst in a stable relationship, I can give a different perspective to this than someone who was disabled from birth or a much younger age as my circumstances may be completely different.


So do I agree with Dr Phil then…..?

Well, to be honest, I think it’s not a binary option, that it either does or doesn’t work; it’s such a difficult situation to find yourself in, it’s all down to the people involved and as usual personal relationships are so very complex and complicated. 




When IT happened to me, it was such a slow descent into disabilty that we were constantly looking for what we would do when I recovered. When we were told that this would not be the case, I would be lying if I said it didn’t affect us as a couple. Being in constant pain is no fun and then being told it was permanent, I withdrew into a black hole with my darling P trying to remain upbeat and trying to help me out of my depression. 

But then as I emerged and started to feel stronger and more confident and ready to claim my disability and to try and advocate for disabilty rights, P was suddenly hit with his own ‘black hole’. His desire to love and protect me sometimes clashed with my need to get out and push myself too hard. He then found that he had to ‘pick up the pieces‘ when the inevitable crash and huge pain spike came and I needed his nursing.


He is the one who has to help me with my personal needs, he is the one who has to do all the household chores and tasks and he is the one who has to hold me at night when the strong painkillers bring the night terrors and the hallucinations. (Seeing green swarms of absolute horror at 4am is no fun believe me)


grayscale photo of woman covering her face by her hand


And in his words, he is the one who ‘feels lonely when he now has to do things alone when we used to do them together“. (Yep, that made me tear up when I heard it too…..)

A relationship which has to undergo a huge change is bound to have a few ‘tremors’ but I think the thing that Dr Phil ignores is the presence of the oldest feeling in the world – Love. 

Love is the thing that binds you together, that seals the deals you make together, the reason that you put up with dopey annoyances; the shoes left in the middle of the hall, the towels left on the floor, the empty glass left on the side of the sink instead of in the dishwasher, and the thing that in these instances, stops you running for the hills and just giving up. 


It is this love that you hear of throughout all those #100outof100 tweets, comments and blogs. This is the love that conquers couples who have faced spinal injuries, paralysis, strokes, heart disease, chronic illnesses, physical and mental health conditions and a multitude of other issues. 

And it is this love which defies whatever Dr Phil or anyone else says; yes, love is challenged when these things occur, and don’t get me wrong, these things could happen to anyone of us at anytime, and this is when the strength of your love is tested, but real love, true love does not drop out and run away, it’s stays, says “ok, this is crappy but let’s get through this together“.

Sounds good to me so seeing as I love P and P loves me, we’ll just carry on facing whatever life decides to fling at us and do as the poster says, “keep calm and carry on”!

What the hell does Dr Phil know?!? 😘



8 Replies to “Can love with a disabled person last? A Valentine Day’s musing………”

  1. So glad that I am not Mrs Dr Phil! Our life is not easy, everything has changed and some things have gone but it is pretty fair to say that we definitely still love each other.


    1. I know, life is difficult sometimes but we have to hang on to the love that binds us I think. Thanks for your comment! Xx


  2. For a Doctor to say “can be his lover or you can be his caregiver, but you can’t be both…. It won’t work, 100 out of 100 times this won’t work” tells me that the Doctor doesn’t understand people. I’m sure that some relationships may well be as he describes, but 100 out of a 100 is an absolute certainty! There may be absolute certainties in physics and chemistry but there is no such thing in human hearts and minds. In human history it is not unusual to find instances of parents, siblings and spouses sacrificing their lives for their loved ones. Love is not only ‘physical’ it is a state of mind, a state of bliss, I personally think if you love a disabled person it might be hard and possibly trying at times but at the same time the same hard or trying time can be, if you truly love your partner, a rewarding and fulfilling part of a beautiful relationship. Life is never perfect. Just my thoughts.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Usually, I like what Dr. Phil says. Joe and I have been married 53 years, over 40 of which I’ve had increasing limitations. He is both my lover and my caregiver. It isn’t easy but is doable.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Carole, thanks for your comment – I think that’s exactly what I was saying, that it not be easy but it’s most definitely possible!


  4. Great post. I think Dr Phil made a very shallow statement.

    Love your post, Linley.

    I wouldn’t class myself as disabled when I met my husband, but I did live with chronic pain. Just a year after meeting him, my back did disable me. Then after being married for 2 years, I had to retire from work. We’ve been married for over 27 years, together for over 29.

    He didn’t disappear when it was obvious that I had a lifelong disability, He didn’t stick around all those years just for the sake of it. He didn’t stay because his lifetime goal was to be a caregiver to his wife. Love…that’s what got us together and that’s what has kept us together.

    Nothing is plain sailing in life, but to make the statement that love and caregiving don’t go together is wrong.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi, thanks so much for your comments, I totally agree with your sentiments. It’s ridiculous to say that it can’t ever work, both yourself and I are examples where it can not only work but flourish. Thanks again for the support.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s